carving ethics

["George Graham" <georgergraham@zzzzzzzzzzz>]

Clive,
as usual , your thoughtful and gentle responses cut to the chase of an
issue. What are we saying to beginners looking for advice from this list.
I can't bring myself to tell someone to not try a modern grinder if they
really want to. While I completely agree with the negative aspects of using
a grinder, the plus side is that experimenting with such a tool just adds to
the knowledge and experience a beginner needs. This may sound cruel, but I
feel that if the instincts to know what good sculpture is, are not in an
individual to start with , then the process and tools used are not going to
matter in the long run. Flipping that statement around, I also think that a
person with the natural instinct to carve and sculpt, will rise above the
limitations of tools and technology, and do artwork that has  heart and soul
in their work.

The funny thing about this discussion and many  others over the last few
years is that I often find myself advocating and giving advice on the high
tech tools of stone work, and giving the impression that I prefer high tech
over old fashioned methods. My preference of tool is driven by my needs of
the moment, what the stone forces me to do , and what I want to create. I
only use power tools for those times when they can save me some time in the
rough out stage on marble, and don't see a need for power tools at all when
I'm working in soapstone, alabaster, and Indiana limestone. Granite forces
me to reach for the diamond blade, and air hammer.

So , back to the real issue, what should we advise beginners? While all the
experienced carvers have developed their own style of carving, the beginners
have different needs. My advice starts with the premise that you should just
do it, and let the chips fall where they may, and learn from your mistakes!
After thinking about what you said on ethics, my advice may be just a little
harsh. I've never considered myself a teacher, but your thoughts have me
being a little more sensitive to the needs of an excited beginner.
Thanks for sharing your insights,Clive.
George Graham